What Self-Compassion Actually Looks Like for Perfectionists

Written By Rachel McDonough

If you’re a perfectionist, you’ve likely spent a lot of time striving, achieving, and holding yourself to high standards. You push through, overthink, and replay your “mistakes” long after anyone else has moved on. But when someone tells you to “practice self-compassion,” you might feel confused—or even annoyed.

Be kind to myself? How? What does that even look like?

Self-compassion gets tossed around a lot in therapy and wellness spaces, but for perfectionists, it can feel vague or unrealistic. So let’s break it down clearly—what self-compassion actually means, why it’s so hard if you lean perfectionist, and how to start practicing it in real life.

What Self-Compassion Really Means (Not Just Saying Nice Things)

Self-compassion isn’t letting yourself off the hook. It’s not laziness or an excuse to stop trying. And it’s definitely not just saying nice things to yourself in the mirror.

Self-compassion is treating yourself with the same kindness, patience, and understanding you’d offer a close friend.

That means when you mess up, instead of saying:

“You’re so stupid.”
You say: “You made a mistake. That doesn’t define you.”

When you’re overwhelmed, instead of saying:

“Why can’t you handle this better?”
You say: “You’re doing a lot. It makes sense you’re tired.”

It’s a mindset shift—from punishment to support.

Why It’s So Hard for Perfectionists to Practice Self-Compassion

Perfectionism thrives on the belief that your worth is tied to your performance. You might think:

  • If I’m hard on myself, I’ll do better.

  • If I’m not perfect, I’ll disappoint everyone.

  • If I let up, I’ll fall apart.

Self-compassion feels risky. It might seem like weakness or like you’re giving up control. You may even believe that being kind to yourself will make you lazy or unmotivated.

But research shows the opposite. People who practice self-compassion:

  • Bounce back more easily after setbacks

  • Experience less anxiety and depression

  • Stay motivated—not less

Why? Because they’re not burning all their energy beating themselves up.

4 Everyday Examples of Self-Compassion for Perfectionists

Let’s make it concrete. Here are a few real-life ways self-compassion can show up—especially if you lean perfectionist.

  1. Accepting “Good Enough” as Truly Enough

You stop editing the email for the tenth time.
You send the store-bought cupcakes instead of baking from scratch.
You resist apologizing for your house being “a mess” when it’s not.

You remind yourself: Done is better than perfect.

2. Letting Yourself Rest—Without Earning It

You don’t need to finish the to-do list before lying down.
You don’t need to hit a goal before taking a break.
You’re allowed to be tired, simply because you’re human.

Self-compassion says: Rest isn’t a reward. It’s a need.

3. Talking to Yourself Like You’d Talk to a Friend

That voice in your head? The one that calls you lazy or selfish or dramatic?
Start asking: Would I ever talk to a friend like this?

You’d never call someone a failure for not doing it all.

Try saying: “I know you’re doing your best.”

4. Catching All-or-Nothing Thinking

Perfectionists often think in extremes:

  • I ruined everything

  • This always happens

  • If I can’t do it perfectly, I shouldn’t bother

Self-compassion helps you shift to:
“This was hard today, but that doesn’t mean I’m failing.”

But What If I Don’t Feel Like I Deserve It?

Here’s the truth: self-compassion isn’t something you earn.
You don’t have to be crushing it to deserve kindness.
You get to offer it—especially when you’re struggling.

If you're thinking:

  • But I messed up

  • I was snappy with my kid

  • I procrastinated all day

That’s exactly when you need self-compassion.
Because shame doesn’t help you grow. But kindness does.

A Simple Practice to Try This Week

Pick a moment when you felt like you failed, fell short, or disappointed yourself.

Ask yourself:

  • What was I feeling in that moment?

  • What would I say to a friend going through the same thing?

  • How can I offer that same message to myself right now?

Even one pause like this helps you build a softer, more supportive inner voice.

You Don’t Have to Be So Hard on Yourself

If perfectionism is running the show, it doesn’t mean you’re broken. It probably means you’re tired—mentally and emotionally. Therapy can help you notice these patterns and replace criticism with care. You don’t have to keep pushing through it alone.

Let’s work together → Schedule a Free 15 Minute Consultation

You Might Also Like:

Rachel McDonough
Next

Why You Don’t Have to Love Every Moment of Motherhood